Old Trail Inn

Old Trail Inn, nestled in Hadley, New York, offers an authentic American dining experience that has garnered favorable attention since its new management took the helm. Customers rave about the consistently good food, highlighted by their excellent burgers and pizzas, with one patron even labeling it as "the best." The menu features a variety of options, from hearty quesadillas to satisfying chicken Parmesan specials, ensuring there's something for everyone.

What truly sets Old Trail Inn apart is its customer service. Diners appreciate the friendly and attentive staff, including the owner who often takes the time to connect with guests personally. The ambiance might lean towards the rustic, but the value for money and the quality of meals are impressively high. Many reviews commend the reasonable prices and occasional specials that allow for enjoyable dining without breaking the bank.

However, like any establishment, Old Trail Inn has faced its share of criticism. Some customers have mentioned inconsistencies with food quality, particularly with pizza offerings on certain days. Nevertheless, the overall sentiment leans toward satisfaction, with patrons eager to return time and again. If you find yourself in the area, Old Trail Inn seems to deliver a delightful mix of comfort and quality in a homey setting.